In the recent financial reports released by Japan's three major automakers, the industry faced stark realities as they unveiled their fiscal performances. The aftermath of their disclosures reflects challenges that extend beyond mere numbers; it's about the shifting tides in consumer preferences, market competition, and the broader landscape of the global automotive industry.

Toyota, a titan of the automotive world, reported a sales revenue of 23.28 trillion yen, which signifies a notable year-on-year growth of 5.9%. However, it also reported a drop in operating profit to 2.46 trillion yen, down by 3.7%, while its net profit plummeted by an alarming 26.4% to 1.9 trillion yen. The figures symbolize both resilience in revenue generation and vulnerability in profit margins amidst an evolving market.

Honda also found itself on the back foot, reporting a sales revenue of 5.39 trillion yen. Its operating profit stood at 257.9 billion yen, and its net profit at 100 billion yen – all below market expectations, casting a shadow on the company’s operational efficacy and growth strategy.

Nissan's performance was particularly troubling, as it reported a sales revenue of 2.99 trillion yen, reflecting a year-on-year decline of 5.08%. Even more concerning was the stark contrast in operating profit, which fell dramatically by 84.67% to 31.91 billion yen, culminating in a net loss of 93.4 billion yen, which severely underperformed against the anticipated profit of 49.07 billion yen. This revelation not only highlights Nissan's struggles but also signifies a potential crisis brewing within the company.

Advertisement

In a desperate bid to remedy its faltering performance, Nissan has rolled out an urgent series of measures, aimed at significant cost-cutting and efficiency improvements. This includes a staggering 20% global production capacity reduction, an initiative to lay off 9,000 employees around the world, and an unprecedented decision where executives, including the CEO, voluntarily forgo 50% of their monthly salaries. Such drastic measures are indicative of the depth of the trouble that Nissan is currently navigating.

The ladders of loss are stark; Nissan has also revised its fiscal 2024 operating profit forecast down to 150 billion yen, a significant reduction from their earlier estimates, which already saw cuts in July from 600 billion yen to 500 billion yen. This downward spiral from 600 to 500 and now to 150 billion yen bespeaks a profound pessimism regarding the company’s future performance. The urgency to reverse course is underscored by a 4% decline in global sales between April and September this year, with the most severe drops occurring within the Chinese market.

In October, Nissan reported sales figures of 57,323 vehicles in China, down a staggering 16.52% year-on-year. The performance of their popular model, the Sylphy (known as Xuanyi in China), is central to Nissan’s sales composition, accounting for over half of their sales volume. With Xuanyi alone selling 31,942 units, which is approximately 55.7% of Nissan’s total, its popularity represents both a strength and a weakness for the brand.

Having enjoyed status as one of China's best-selling cars from 2020 to 2021, the Xuanyi's annual sales still hover around 300,000 units, cementing its place as a leading fuel vehicle. What is particularly impressive is its consistent market appeal since entering the Chinese scene in 2006, garnering a cumulative sales figure of 5 million units over the years. This longevity reflects a commitment to performance, comfort, and reliability that Japanese automakers pride themselves on.

However, the sustained success of the Xuanyi raises critical questions about Nissan's product innovation in the Chinese market. The model serves as a double-edged sword; it’s a testament to Nissan’s ability to cater to consumer needs, but simultaneously, it reflects a lack of innovation that raises concerns among consumers. Newer releases like the Sylphy e-Power and the Classic version, while aiming to broaden appeal, may come off as rehashing old designs with minimal differentiation.

From a product positioning perspective, Xuanyi’s ability to thrive can be attributed to its focus on the family sedan market segment. Its strategy appears somewhat simplistic; it is targeting the consumer demographic that prefers affordable, reliable cars. Over the years, its price point has seen dramatic reductions, a strategy that effectively exchanged volume for value. Once priced around 120,000 yen, the entry point has drastically dropped to approximately 70,000 yen, showcasing an aggressive pricing tactic that compromises profit margins.

However, the dual concerns accompanying this strategy include the intense competition in the Chinese automotive market that continues to thrive on aggressive pricing and the rapid growth of electric vehicles. As compound annual growth rates for electric vehicles surpass 50%, questions loom over the future viability of the traditional fuel vehicle cohort that Xuanyi so heavily caters to.

The market responses have already begun to spell trouble. In the first nine months of this year, the best-selling compact sedan in China was the BYD's Han series, an electric vehicle that underlines the consumer shift away from conventional offerings. With Nissan's sales heavily reliant on Xuanyi, any further decline may well signal the end of the road for Nissan in China.

Cognizant of its precarious position, Nissan's CEO Makoto Uchida has pledged a restructuring plan that aims not only to streamline business operations but also to enhance resilience, particularly in the volatile Chinese market. Specific strategies include the introduction of eight new electric models tailored for the Chinese market by 2026, which will consist of five models under the Nissan brand. Despite the planning, critics argue that Nissan's pace in adopting electrification and embracing technological advancements has been disappointingly slow.

This struggle with innovation does not solely define Nissan; it reflects a wider malaise seen across Japanese automakers. Toyota’s sales in China plummeted by 13.7% in the first half of this fiscal year, while Honda's figures dropped by an alarming 31% in the first 10 months of the year. The juxtaposition of their mostly hybrid-centric focus against an electrification trend heralds the challenge they face in the marketplace.

While Toyota stays steadfast in its belief that fully electric vehicles will capture a maximum market share of around 30%, the necessity to pivot and invest in electric mobility has become unavoidable against the backdrop of fierce competition. Honda, undergoing its transformation with the establishment of its first global electric vehicle plant in China, is just now taking its first steps in electrification, raising questions about the timing and impact of its initiatives.

The arduous journey Japanese automakers are experiencing evokes an image of a frog in boiling water, slowly succumbing to external pressures without a robust response. The stakes are high, and the course they choose to take today will undeniably shape the future of their legacy in the automotive landscape.